04 November 2010

A Call for More Rage

If Chris Hedges published "The Phantom Left" back on Sunday, I can only imagine how he feels, or what he might write, after Tuesday's elections. Hedges, an antiwar writer who has also found time to swipe at atheists in a busy publishing career, seems to have been provoked by last weekend's Comedy Central rally in Washington. John Stewart's pleas for moderate politics and moderate rhetoric only inspired disgust in Hedges.

The rally delivered a political message devoid of reality or content. The corruption of electoral politics by corporate funds and lobbyists ... was ignored for emotional catharsis. The right hates. The liberals laugh. And the country is taken hostage. The Rally to Restore Sanity, held in Washington’s National Mall, was yet another sad footnote to the death of the liberal class. It was as innocuous as a Boy Scout jamboree.
Hedges is annoyed by Stewart's attempted delegitimization of anger as a force in politics. His view is that Americans have every right and ample cause to be angry -- including the Tea Partiers. Stewart "ridiculed followers of the tea party without acknowledging that the pain and suffering expressed by many who support the movement are not only real but legitimate," Hedges writes. "Fox News’ Beck and his allies on the far right can use hatred as a mobilizing force because there are tens of millions of Americans who have very good reason to hate."

The only problem with TP anger, Hedges suggests, is that people like Beck steer it in the wrong directions. If anything, he argues, more Americans should be angry across the political spectrum. He complains that there's only a "phantom left" in the country, something little more than a figment of the center-right imagination, because those labeled as leftists by the center and the right have done next to nothing to articulate the people's grievances against corporate power in the angry langauge they deserve. Liberals themselves, the "phantom left" of reactionary fantasy, preach moderation, accommodation, compromise and acquiescence instead of resistance.

As long as the liberal class speaks in the dead voice of moderation it will continue to fuel the right-wing backlash. Only when it appropriates this rage as its own, only when it stands up to established systems of power, including the Democratic Party, will we have any hope of holding off the lunatic fringe of the Republican Party.
To Hedges, this is no time for moderation. He envisions the onset of corporate-ruled "neofeudalism" in the aftermath of the "internal collapse" of a debt-ridden republic. In the face of such a threat, "Being nice and moderate will not help," nor will "funny signs, comics dressed up as Captain America or nice words." What, then, does he recommend?

If the liberal class concedes that power has been wrested from us it will be forced, if it wants to act, to build movements outside the political system. This would require the liberal class to demand acts of resistance, including civil disobedience, to attempt to salvage what is left of our anemic democratic state. But this type of political activity, as costly as it is difficult, is too unpalatable to a bankrupt liberal establishment that has sold its soul to corporate interests.
Hedges, presumably, will go on promoting his new book, The Death of the Liberal Class, no doubt summoning the masses to the barricades at every stop on the tour. If that sounds harsh from me, it's because I see it as one thing for someone like Hedges to "demand acts of resistance," and another for him to perform them. Writing a book or a column doesn't cut it, any more than posting to a blog does. For the moment, he seems more likely to profit from his outrage than to risk and costs. Again, I don't mean to say that I think he's wrong about the state of affairs in this country. I just think that if he's going to be that judgmental toward John Stewart and all the media, he ought to reflect on the extent to which he is a creature of the same media. He can go all situationist on us and speak out against the society of the spectacle, but he's part of it -- perhaps he should consult Marcuse rather than Debord, says the smartass -- until I see proof to the contrary. That proof won't be in an opinion column.

03 November 2010

NY23: The Fault is Still Shifting

Last year, New York's 23rd Congressional district captured the nation's attention briefly when its representative's appointment to the Defense Department forced a special election. In what was arguably the first real test of tea-partry power, local conservatives repudiated the Republican candidate selected by county party bosses, the allegedly too-liberal Dede Scozzafava, and rallied behind Conservative party candidate Doug Hoffman. Despite nationwide publicity from the right-wing media, Hoffman's independent campaign fell short, and Democrat Bill Owens won the formerly Republican district.

Defying the national trend, Owens was re-elected to a full term yesterday after a campaign that may have revealed NY23 as the epicenter of conservative dysfunction. The trouble began before the primaries, when the Conservatives again endorsed Hoffman, but Republican county leaders again rejected him, this time in favor of Matt Doheny. Hoffman duly challenged Doheny in the Republican primary (there was no time for a primary the year before), but despite his celebrity in conservative circles, he reportedly waged a surprisingly weak campaign. In September, Doheny won the primary. Hoffman had the Conservative line and could not be taken off; unlike onetime Conservative gubernatorial candidate Rick Lazio, Hoffman had no judgeship to run for as a consolation prize, so under New York rules the Conservatives were stuck with him, even after Hoffman endorsed Doheny in October.

Despite publicly disavowing his campaign and endorsing the Republican, Hoffman received more than 7,000 votes yesterday, more than the margin separating Doheny from Owens. In the aftermath of this local disaster, Doheny has accused Hoffman of supporting him too little and too late, while Hoffman blames the GOP leadership for again rejecting him way back in January. In his view, once the Republicans realized that Hoffman would have the Conservative line, they should have played ball and given him their endorsement before the primary. That reasoning didn't work for Rick Lazio's supporters and it didn't work for Hoffman. Now, the disappointed Conservative for all intents and purposes repudiates independent politics, calling on Conservatives and Republicans to work together when there's no automatic reason for them to do so.

My understanding when I learned of Hoffman's withdrawal last month was that Doheny was considered at least a more conservative Republican than the accursed Scozzafava. He may still have been insufficiently conservative for Hoffman's die-hard fans, but their votes yesterday may also have been a protest against the local GOP establishment, who obviously hold some kind of grudge against Hoffman. Many Hoffman voters may have decided that representation by a Democrat who's reportedly a personal friend of Bill O'Reilly (and whom O'Reilly reportedly said he'd vote for if he lived in the district) was less obnoxious than dictation from an unrepresentative Republican leadership.

As we see Republicans and conservatives maneuvering for position in the race for a presidential nomination, we'll want to keep an eye on personal rivalries as well as ideological disagreements, as well as the ways they feed each other. The personal apparently was political in the 23rd district, and it put the local right wing at the back of the class of 2010 when they seemed to be the vanguard in 2009.

Second Chance?

Republican party chairman Steele, Speaker-presumptive Boehner, Majority Whip-presumptive Cantor and Senator-elect Rubio from Florida have all described the result of yesterday's elections as a "second chance" for the Republican party to earn the lasting trust of American voters. These leaders apparently lack any consciousness of their own party's history.

The first Republican Speaker of the House acquired the gavel in 1860. Republicans controlled the House through the Civil War and for most of the Reconstruction era, until the 1874 congressional elections. The Republicans' second chance actually came way back in 1880, when they regained control of the House. That second chance lasted for one congressional term. Republicans' third chance arrived following the 1888 elections. That also lasted for a single term. Their fourth chance lasted somewhat longer, from 1895 through the 1910 elections. By 1918 voters were ready to give the GOP its fifth chance, which lasted until the Great Depression. After World War II, New Deal-fatigue and the first stirrings of anti-commie hysteria resulted in Republicans getting a sixth chance. During those two years they won the reputation of a do-nothing Congress. Before long, riding the coattails of Dwight Eisenhower, the Republicans got their seventh chance in 1952. Two years later, their long exile began, ending only when voters gave the Gingrich-led GOP its eighth chance in 1994. Burned by Bush, the electorate ended Republican control in 2006, only to give the party its ninth chance yesterday. To be fair, however, I should note that the Democrats, having existed longer than the Republicans, have had several more chances. It makes my point just as well.

Do Steele, Boehner, Cantor and Rubio want us to believe -- do they believe themselves -- that the Republican party only came into existence in 1994? If so, what party did Ronald Reagan belong to? Judging by presidential elections alone, Republicans in 2012 will be asking for their third chance to earn Americans' trust if we start counting only from the Reagan-Bush period. While it's true that Republican ideological evolution has been erratic, and that the party can hardly claim to have upheld any principle consistently from its founding to the present, it's historically dishonest even to imply that today's GOP is somehow not the same institution that's been hogging one end of the political tug-of-war rope for the past 150 years or so. Of course, none of the above leaders may have meant to say that. They might say "Republican" but they probably mean the radio-controlled reactionary movement that did come of age in 1994. But that movement chose to link its destiny with the contradictory heritage of the Republican party and can't shake off that heritage so easily. As for their audience, Americans need to understand that both major parties have been given more chances than they deserve. How many more chances do we give ourselves -- how many more do we have -- to get this right?

Congratulations to Howie Hawkins

Third place means nothing in an American election, and 1% of the vote usually means even less, but as of 11:18 this morning, with most of New York's districts having reported, Green Party gubernatorial candidate Howie Hawkins has accumulated 56,633 votes. To be more exact, that's 1.38% of the votes counted so far, but as long as it's more than 50,000, Hawkins has earned the Green Party an automatic line on the state ballot until the next gubernatorial election. In 2014 the Greens will not have to run obstacle course of petition collection and will be free to concentrate such resources as they'll have on seeking votes rather than signatures. Objectively speaking, the result is still shamefully low and reflects poorly on New Yorkers' capacity for independent political thought, but by Empire State standards Hawkins's performance is still a victory and ought to be celebrated as such.

Meanwhile, it's still uncertain whether Warren Redlich will bring the Libertarian Party across the same finish line. He had 44,537 votes at the last count, good enough for fourth place and 1.09% of the total. Redlich may have suffered from a split libertarian vote. Assuming that the 22,705 people known so far to have voted for Anti-Prohibition candidate Kristin Davis are libertarians by orientation rather than protest or joke voters, the overall libertarian constituency in New York appears to outnumber the independent progressives who voted Green. Had libertarians united behind one candidate, they would have earned an automatic line easily, but it may be characteristic of the species to fall short of unity in political action.

Approximately 4.5% of New York voters opted for independent gubernatorial candidates this year, including 39,740 votes counted so far for Rent is 2 Damn High candidate James McMillan and 20,707 votes for Freedom Party candidate Charles Barron. The independent constituency is as ideologically diverse, at least, as the Bipolarchy electorate that favored Democrat Andrew Cuomo over Republican Carl Paladino. No candidate or cause can hope to unite all 184,322 (and counting) independents. But if there's potential strength in these numbers, it will consist of their capacity to inspire or encourage more New Yorkers to emulate them. The more people vote independently, the less weird or contemptible independent voting will seem to everyone else. What's the threshold number in this case? The state can't set an arbitrary standard here, and we can't identify the objective magic number that will mark a tipping point until we actually pass it. All independents can do is stay independent and set examples for everyone else.

02 November 2010

Citizens United or Citizens Incorporated?

Reason magazine's December cover story is illustrated with pictures of two protesters: on the right, a presumed Tea Partier equating the Democratic leadership with Marx, Lenin and Stalin, and on the left, a woman whose sign reads, "Capitalism is failing. Socialism is the alternative." The cover headline declares, "You Are Now Free to Speak About Politics," then asks, "Why do some people fear a less restricted debate?" The implication from the onset is that the Supreme Court's controversial decision in the Citizens United case should be unobjectionable because it empowers both the bald, surly right-wing crank and the cute commie chick.

But as Jacob Sullum notes inside the magazine, in a reasonably fair-minded story that consults both advocates and enemies of campaign-finance regulation, Citizens United is reviled by the Democratic establishment, if not by the left as a whole, as a license for corporations to buy elections and politicians. Interestingly, Sullum never takes up the line of argument usually inferred as the basis of the Court's decision, that corporations have the right to political speech as a matter of legal "personhood." Instead, he adopts the broadest possible definition of "corporation" to argue, as one law professor puts it, that "everything is incorporated."

The over-the-top reactions to Citizens United reflect a view of corporations as giant, soulless automatons that are fine for producing goods and services in a regulated environment but bound to wreak havoc if let loose in the halls of political power. That view obscures the fact that corporations, no matter how large or profit-driven, are by definition associations of individuals who have joined together for a common purpose. It also misleadingly suggests that behemoths such as Wal-Mart and Exxon Mobil are typical corporations, when in fact the vast majority of the 6 million or so corporations registered in the United States are small businesses or nonprofits....Contrary to all the rhetoric about corporations drowning out the voice of the people, corporations are the voice of the people. [emphasis in original]

Sullum's article traces the evolution of law regarding campaign donations from 1947, when Congress banned spending "in connection with" federal elections by unions and corporations, to Citizens United. The major precedent standing in the way of the Roberts Court, Sullum explains, was the 1990 Austin v. Michigan Chamber of Commerce decision, which affirmed a ban on corporate-funded candidate advertising as a check on "the corrosive and distorting effects of immense aggregations of wealth." During oral arguments in Citizens United, inconsistencies in Austin's reasoning were exposed, since there were no restrictions on spending by super-rich individuals who could spend far more than the allegedly dangerous corporations. The oral arguments, as reported by Sullum, were a dismal performance on the part of the Obama administration's lawyers, who seemed to endorse a government power to ban "express advocacy" propaganda from all media, including books or pamphlets, depending on who addressed the Court. Throughout Sullum's account, Democrats and their agents are open to charges of unfairness and bias against business. Their attempt to trump Citizens United with the DISCLOSE Act seems self-evidently unfair, since the bill, as described by Sullum, restricts corporations with foreign investors but not unions that are avowedly international, and restricts corporations with government contracts but not public employee unions. If you can support the regulation of political advertising without supporting the Democratic party, you should be able to criticize Democratic legislation without repudiating the ideal of levelling the playing field.

Sullum interviews the head of Common Cause, who tells him that without restrictions "rogue corporations" could intimidate legislators merely by threatening to finance an opponent. That idea is challenged by representatives of the Center for Competitive Politics, one of whom tells Sullum that a politician so threatened could "score points with voters" simply by publicizing the threat. The Common Cause man scoffs at that notion -- and he may be right to do so. He doesn't explain why he scoffs, but we might assume that the theoretical politician is not just interested in fending off the corporate threat, but also wants that corporate money for himself.

In any event, Sullum downplays the likelihood of corporate intimidation. The Center for Competitive Politics asserts that the Fortune 500 would "much rather spend their money lobbying" than on buying risky political ads. Target got into trouble recently, for instance, for donating money to a Minnesota organization that ran ads against gay marriage. Threats of boycotts, presumably, cowed the Target CEO into apologizing for its donation. Emphasizing the risk to big companies underscores one of Sullum's larger points, that most "corporate" political spending is done by small businesses, not the "too big to fail" crowd whom many people suspect. This example seems to confirm the CCP's point that publicity deters intimidation, but it doesn't address an important concern ignored by Sullum. The problem of the moment isn't so much politicians' dependence on any clique of large corporations or billionaires, but their dependence upon fundraising itself. Almost unconsciously, however, Sullum invites readers to consider the influx of corporate-funded political advertising as an alternative to party-funded advertising, not to mention the state-funded advertising option which Sullum, as a libertarian, distrusts. Perhaps the ideal under the new conditions is a state of affairs in which the political parties don't have to spend so much time fundraising as long as they can trust sympathizers to buy ads for them. That would leave elected officials free to do the work we hired them for. But to the extent that the major parties have become fundraising machines, they may be jealous of their prerogatives. Partisans may oppose unrestricted corporate spending because it sends money through other channels that might otherwise go to them.

Sullum shows his libertarian colors towards the end, when he challenges the idea that regulations on campaign spending are necessary to "restore trust in government." That object, he writes, "is not as uncontroversial a proposition" as its proponents think, "Surely there is such a thing as too much faith in government, and people of different political persuasions are bound to draw that line in different places." The CCP observes that "there's a problem with the basic idea that people should really trust their government. Our country was founded on people not trusting the government." While you wrestle with that paradox, just accept that libertarians will always err on the side of dissent, even if the business class isn't usually identified with dissent in the public mind.

While the fundraising racket requires reform, our opinions about spending are probably skewed by Bipolarchy thinking. Citizens United, after all, is a group that made a film against Hillary Clinton but was barred from making it available for on-demand viewing on cable TV. It seems to me that people have as much right to denounce Clinton as they would to denounce anyone they deem a public menace, in print, on film or in whatever medium they choose. That right should extend to urging people not to vote for her, but it becomes problematic once people presume that voting against Clinton means voting for someone -- whether a conservative Republican, as Citizens United would have preferred, or Barack Obama, who was the immediate option during the time in question. Denunciation shouldn't be equated automatically with electioneering. I can say, "Don't vote for Republicans today" without being accused of advocating for Democrats, as long as other options exist. In any event, even if Democrats are the only other option I should be able to speak out against Republicans as a matter of conscience in whatever medium I please without being accused of compromising the electoral process. On the same ground, I should be able to argue that fundraising plays too large a role in elections without being accused of favoring the unquestioned rule of a Democratic-liberal nomenklatura. Because we imagine the political scales evenly balanced between two great parties, we're tempted to see any intervention as disrupting a balance wrongly seen as both natural and necessary. To the extent that libertarians in America suffer from bipolarchy consciousness (state vs. "freedom") they're no more likely to view the donation-fundraising question objectively than anyone else. Nevertheless, Sullum has made a good stab at a substantial, informative and challenging account that's worth reading to anyone interested in the question.

Nostalgia and Utopia at the Polls

Maybe it's just me, but there's a cheapness to voting, a sense of diminished grandeur, now that New York State has replaced the good old voting machines with paper ballots and computerized scanners. The dingus that reads your inking of circles may well be more expensive than the old lever machines, but everything else about the new process has a hard-times feeling of retrenchment to it that may well suit the national mood. Once you're recognized and sign in, an election worker gives you your paper ballot inside a folder and directs you to what passes now for a voting booth. This stall has the same basic relation to the old curtained booth as today's few remaining public pay phones have with Clark Kent's archetypal phone booth. There was something inimitable to the voting-booth experience as you yanked the lever to close the curtains; it was like nothing else you did during the year, while the filling in of ovals now is all-too reminiscent of standardized tests in school, and the overall experience is more reminiscent of completing an application for services than of exercising one's sovereign franchise. The only real benefit I saw in the new experience was the certain knowledge from the scanner's screen that I was the 47th person to vote at my polling place this morning.

My nostalgia for the old voting machines, which have been replaced mainly to enrich the scanner manufacturers, is tempered by my reservations about any ballot format that limits your choice of candidates. Seven candidates for governor appear on this year's paper ballot, but five of them had to cross an arbitrary petition threshold in order to be recognized as even theoretical equals to the major-party candidates. Any official ballot, despite its mandate to list all candidates, must limit the number of viable candidates for space reasons, consigning those who don't meet the petition quota to the quasi-anonymity of write-in status. The new system returns us to something like an earlier system of paper ballots, but because they're official ballots and have similar space limitations, there remains an imperative to limit the number of candidates by setting a threshold of viability. At an earlier period of history people could make up their own ballots, simply listing the candidates of their choice, or political parties could print their own straight-ticket ballots for distribution to the faithful. It may have been thought more fair or objective to make the official ballot a list of all candidates, but the maximum range of electoral choices requires a liberation of voters from the tyranny of space restrictions, while playing fields might be levelled somewhat in voters' minds if they didn't always seen Democrats and Republicans on the top lines of ballots. While ballots and lines might be defended as necessary to inform voters of choices they might not know about otherwise, we ought to work toward a time when voice-recognition software would enable people to speak (while accommodating the handicapped) the names of candidates without identifying them with parties or requiring them to jump petition hurdles beforehand.

How did I vote? I see no reason to conceal that I voted straight Green wherever possible, with the exception of the Libertarian candidate for Attorney General, since that strikes me as a good match of job and ideology. Since there was no independent challenger to Paul Tonko, my incumbent Democratic representative, I voted for him. Reflexive hostility to incumbents is no excuse for voting Republican. Tonko will probably be the only person I voted for who wins tonight, unless an upset is in the offing. Whether any of my selections wins is a secondary consideration, however, since my first duty to my fellow citizens is to vote according to my own conscience. This small gesture of publicizing my choices may do more than the votes themselves if it inspires others to vote independently, today or next time.

01 November 2010

The Obama Syndrome

Move far enough to Barack Obama's left and the view begins to resemble that from the President's right. Tariq Ali, for instance, agrees with at least one detail of the ad hominem portrait of the current Chief Executive. As the Pakistani Marxist sees it from his base in Britain, Obama is nothing more than the archetypal Chicago machine politician on the make. In his brief hatchet job, The Obama Syndrome: Surrender at Home, War Abroad, which he promises to expand in time for the 2012 campaign, Ali compares Obama unfavorably with the likes of Malcolm X and the Black Panthers, who are more to the radical author's liking. By comparison, the President is an egotistical opportunist and a toady to the powerful, a willing servant of the American Empire. Ali recounts an unflattering episode from Obama's Illinois legislature days, when he was one of four Democrats to vote for Republican spending cuts in order to look Senatorial, only to threaten to kick the ass of another Democrat when cuts that affected Obama's own constituency, and were opposed by him, were approved. There are plenty of bitter reminiscences from more radical black pols, who for Ali are the uncompromised voice of the poor, resenting Obama's rise to power, and there are plenty of quotes from the man himself for Ali to damn him with. The author is particularly disgusted with Obama's boasting of his friendship with corporate bigwigs and his perpetuation of Bush's wars. He claims to have been skeptical from the beginning, not only about Obama as a person but about the transformative potential of his election. In Ali's opinion, no important social change is possible without mass mobilization to pressure the establishment from below, and electing a black man is no substitute for a radical mass movement -- especially when the man is such as Obama.

As a foreigner, Ali has enough distance to see through the bipolarchy illusion to the reality of an establishment that is not much altered by the tilt of elections from one big party to the other. "The Obama Effect," he writes, "was enhanced by the fact that both Obama's person and his ultramoderate views were anathema to the repellent anchors on Fox TV and the crazed bigots of radio talk shows. If they hated him, he must be fine." American liberals might presume that Fox is the voice of the establishment, and that its opposition proved not only how "fine" Obama was but the threat he presented to that illusory power. Ali doesn't deny that disputes between the major parties are often bitter and vicious, but he finds them ultimately irrelevant to the direction taken by the establishment and the empire in the absence of that necessary pressure from below -- the mass movements to whom he assigns the real credit for the New Deal of the 1930s and the Civil Rights successes of the 1960s.

"Until the emergence of a political movement with a viable sociopolitical and economic alternative perceived by a majority as such, there will be no final crisis of capitalism except in the dreams of those who desire something better," Ali writes. He warns that we can't assume that a movement will form when things get bad enough; "Even the most severe economic crisis does not automatically produce a radical shift in mass consciousness that challenges the dominant view." With "neither external nor internal pressures" currently challenging the "American ruling elite," Ali's small tome is likely to inspire a sense of helplessness, especially since he holds back from urging an all-out revival of Marxism. The most he can do is point to the past or the success of "social movements" in South America, though he has no suggestions for starting such movements here or for adapting them to American distrust of strong men like Hugo Chavez. One can guess Ali's own preferences from his unstinting praise for the Cuban health care system, and it's bracing to read an author who holds the profit motive in such low regard. Since Ali has admitted that The Obama Syndrome is essentially incomplete, we should treat it as a work in progress that might be improved over the next two years by some positive recommendations for mobilizing Americans for social justice. For now, the project seems just a bit cynical on the part of Ali's publisher, Verso, if not on his own part. It strikes me as a counterpart of their anti-Clinton books by the since-apostate Christopher Hitchens, an obvious attempt by an avowed left-wing company to make money from progressive discontent with a Democratic regime. They owe us something more substantial between now and 2012.

The Stewart Doctrine:does democracy take itself too seriously?

Having just read a book about the Founding Fathers, I couldn't help feeling a little scandalized while reading Kathleen Parker's weekend critique of the President's appearance on Comedy Central's Daily Show. While from a Founding perspective Obama had already debased himself almost beyond recover by appearing on John Stewart's talk show, Parker complained that the President was still taking himself too seriously during his appearance. After an admittedly embarrassing (if not telling) moment when Obama used the exact same awful phrase that his predecessor used to praise his FEMA chief -- "heckuva job" -- to describe Larry Summers' work for him, his recovery to Stewart's chiding -- "pun intended," -- seemed hopelessly lame to Parker. She felt that the President should have gone for a broader punch line to admit that he'd made a rhetorical goof (if not a Freudian slip). For Parker, this was another failure of Obama to connect on a gut level with the American public.

[I]t is imperative that leaders not take themselves too seriously. What should Obama have done instead? How about saying: "I can't believe I just said that"? Or, "Oy!"? Whatever. Anything to signal to the audience that, "Oh, well, I'm human." But Obama isn't very good at human.


To the Founders, the idea that a President should make a fool of himself to win public favor would have seemed insane. On the other hand, many Americans of minimal historical literacy may assume that Lincoln would have gone out there and topped Stewart with one-liners without really trying. American notions of political dignity and popularity have evolved -- if that's the right word -- over time. For many observers, casual or not, we've reached a point when taking politics and politicians less seriously is an imperative, regardless of what the politicians themselves think.

Parker's column appeared on the morning of John Stewart's big rally in Washington DC. Stewart is the man of the moment for people who want a de-escalation of partisan and ideological invective. That he has the potential to sway multitudes was acknowledged by the President's visit to his show, but he is an unusual demagogue in his apparently passionate advocacy of political dispassion. If I understand him correctly (and I've only seen second-hand reports of Saturday's rally) he actually has the right attitude for a liberal democratic republic. As I've been writing recently, representative democracy flourishes in an environment of reasoned indifference to the outcome of elections. Under ideal conditions, each person votes for whomever seems best qualified for an office, but no one assumes any candidate to be so unqualified that his or her election would be an intolerable threat to the republic. There can be least favorite candidates, but not "worst" ones. Once some candidate or party is perceived as a threat to the republic, there's a dangerous tendency toward a Bipolarchy as demagogues declare themselves the sole bulwark against the threat. Our present Bipolarchy evolved as the Republican party emerged as the sole bulwark against the "slave power" that remained identified with the Democratic party for decades after the Civil War ended. Twenty years after the fact, Republicans still warned that Democratic victories would put Confederates in charge of the Union. The same attitude prevails today among Republicans who cry "socialism" against Democrats and Democrats who cry "racism," etc. against Republicans. Stewart counsels, in satirical fashion, against since bipolarizing invective, and for his trouble he's been criticized by the right-wing talkers of Fox News and the liberal talkers of MSNBC alike. For Stewart's fans, that may be the most persuasive proof that he's onto something. They claim to share his view that these are "hard times" but not "the End Times," -- but what follows practically from that viewpoint?

While Stewart's anti-ideological stance may be the appropriate attitude for representative democracy, the discussion can't end there. It still doesn't follow that liberal democracy is the answer for the present socio-economic crisis, or the global crises that loom on the horizon. In crisis times it may not be a matter of indifference who wins elections, while from a more challenging perspective the crises may be so grave that resolving them should not be left up to popular deliberation. To say that "freedom" solves all problems could well be wishful thinking. If so, who wins elections and who holds power should be a matter of severe importance to everyone. For some Americans, that sense of crisis is only exacerbated if neither of the officially "viable" choices available seems suitable to the tasks at hand. In that case, Stewart may be perfectly right to dissuade people from taking the feuds of Republicans and Democrats as seriously as partisans themselves insist. But it would not follow that politics itself should not be taken most seriously or debated with the urgency of the times. Some of us feel it necessary to attack the two-party system as a whole with as much vehemence as the two parties aim at each other; would Stewart say that we are wrong? His answer could determine the usefulness of whatever movement he calls into being.

29 October 2010

The Nation: Mouthpiece of the Working Families Party

Katrina vanden Heuvel says, "...if you can vote for the WFP this election, do it." She's the editor and publisher of The Nation, the small-n nation's leading liberal weekly, and the WFP, of course, is the Working Families Party. The WFP has sent me a mailing reprinting vanden Heuvel's blanket endorsement, which originally appeared on the Nation website. It follows closely after the magazine's November 1 issue, featuring Alyssa Katz's cover-story defense of the WFP against "the corporate backlash."

While both vanden Heuval and Katz admirably accentuate the positive and refuse to cast slurs, I infer from this campaign that The Nation has either no use or no liking for the Green party. The magazine's hateful attitude toward former Green standard bearer Ralph Nader is well known, but I'm surprised that vanden Heuval and her writers still hold such a grudge. You can read an implicit criticism of the Greens in the editor's endorsement letter, in which she emphasizes "the importance of being principled and pragmatic -- striking a balance between a transformative politics aimed at a fundamentally different, humane and sustainable society, and the compromises often necessary to address people's immediate needs and begin moving toward bolder reforms."

Between the lines, vanden Heuval continues to advocate constructive engagement with the Democratic party instead of competitive confrontation. Greens may dream of replacing the Democrats someday, or simply surpassing them, but vanden Heuval hints in her reference to "people's immediate needs" that compromise and accommodation will always be necessary for progressives. Any sustained campaign to replace the Democrats as the dominant progressive party (in the public mind, however belatedly) will inevitably mean Republican victories. Those are sacrifices vanden Heuval is unwilling to make, and she clearly believes that poor people shouldn't have to pay whatever price comes with the sacrifice.

Of course, The Nation has to prove that the WFP's constructive-engagement policy actually has a progressive effect on Democratic party politics. The simplest approach is to credit Working Families with anything progressive accomplished by the Democrats, not to mention the election of any progressive Democratic candidate. Perhaps more significantly, Katz credits the WFP with getting progressive candidates elected in Democratic primaries, citing this year's primary for attorney general and the toppling of the vulnerable, scandal-plagued Pedro Espada as examples of the New York party's continued strength despite a succession of scandals presumably manufactured as part of the "corporate backlash." Throughout her article, Katz repeats the WFP line that voting for Democrats on their line gives Working Families special leverage with Democratic winners. A more implicit argument is that people who vote WFP but remain registered Democrats can have a decisive influence in Democratic primaries. That may be true in some races, but local experience proves that both Democrats and Republicans often have decisive influence in WFP primaries wherever the party has failed to maintain or even establish cohesive local organizations.

Some readers may choke on their chuckles as Katz describes the "uncompromising demands" of the WFP and its "power over the Democratic Party" in light of the party's utter capitulation to Andrew Cuomo's austerity agenda. Katz can't avoid the story, and acknowledges that the WFP's likely "deference" to Cuomo presents a challenge to the party's integrity and future. "Why have a progressive party if it isn't free to be, well, progressive?" she asks, while an unidentified "consultant close to the party" asks, "How much is too much? At what point have you lost your way?" The questions hang in space while Katz recites a litany of "stunning success," but she returns to the challenge near the end. "The party must look ahead to a fresh, Cuomo-friendly way to advance its vision," she writes. Her own recommendation: "That means pressing legislators and agencies to invest in everything from energy-efficiency retrofits to public transportation, not only to create good jobs but to lower the cost of living and raise the quality of life for everyone." That sounds like lobbying to me, and there may be a place in politics for a lobby based solely on numbers of voters, not millions of dollars. But the WFP model remains ultimately complacent, grounded in enduring faith in the malleability of the Democratic Party and a fatalistic concession of its permanence. Since WFP partisans accept the Bipolarchial premise that Republican rule for any time would be an immediate if not irrevocable disaster, they can never truly force any issue on Democrats or threaten to withhold their support. And if, after all these reputed successes, their own seal of approval is assumed by them to be insufficient to win 50,000 votes for an independent candidate for governor, how powerful are they, really? Working Families may brandish vanden Heuval's letter or Katz's cover story as important endorsements, but they strike me as desperate cries for help. "Who's Afraid of Progressive Power?" The Nation asks, but its editorial line is a fearful admission of progressive powerlessness.

28 October 2010

Who's Afraid of Warren Redlich?

Earlier today I suggested that truly competitive multiparty elections would reduce the volume of negative campaigning. As if to prove me wrong, my mail this evening includes not one, but two pieces of negative campaign literature targeting neither Republicans nor Democrats, but Libertarian gubernatorial candidate Warren Redlich.

The first is a mailing billing Anti-Prohibition candidate Kristin Davis as "the real libertarian candidate." One side slams Redlich for proposing higher gas taxes. The other touts the Davis platform of eliminating capital gains taxes, slashing business franchise taxes, cutting state income tax rates, ending marijuana prohibition and legalizing casino gambling.

The second is a sleazy production from "People for a Safer New York," a group so obscure that you can't google it. This mailing is a sealed fold-out billing itself as a "Sexual Predator Alert." Open it, and you read that Redlich allegedly "defends sex with children." For that reason, he "constitutes a public danger." Losing track of the narrative, the flier identifies Redlich himself as a "sick twisted pervert...advocating his sick views running as a libertine candidate for governor." It goes so far as to tell readers to "Call the Police!" if they see Redlich in the neighborhood or near a public school. The authors' basis for this hysterical screed is a blog post Redlich wrote in 2008 on the controversy over a racy Miley Cyrus photoshoot. He recalls that no such fuss was made when Brooke Shields filmed The Blue Lagoon, and notes the Shakespearean precedent for sexually active teenage girls. He speculates that it was once considered normal for older men to be interested in Juliet-aged girls, but adds, as a parent of two, that he'll need "a shotgun or two" to keep men away from his daughters. From such slight stuff "People for a Safer New York" have concocted the most despicable piece of campaign literature I've seen in some time.

As everyone will tell you, Redlich has "no chance" to be elected Governor next Tuesday. So why is anyone spending time and money attacking him? Davis's attack is probably more understandable. In the current angry environment there may be enough votes out there to earn a libertarian party a guaranteed ballot line for the next state elections. Anti-Prohibition is arguably competing with the Libertarian Party for 50,000 gubernatorial votes, so Davis wants to prover herself more libertarian than Redlich. As for "People for a Safer New York," I have no idea who they support, but I have to assume that they, too, don't want the Libertarians to get that ballot line. It almost makes me want to vote for Redlich next week just to stick it to those jerks.

Negativity Defines Bipolarchy

On the radio a morning or so ago NPR played some excerpts from a California gubernatorial debate. Whoever else was running, the stage was reserved for former Governor Jerry Brown, the Democratic nominee, and EBay magnate Meg Whitman, the Republican. Their contest must have been tough for Californians to watch until then, for the crowd rose in stormy applause when the moderator challenged both candidates to dispense with "negativity" for the duration of the campaign. When Brown argued that negativity was "in the eye of the beholder," he was booed loudly. When Whitman insisted on her obligation to call attention to aspects of Brown's record, she was booed, too.

Both candidates must have considered both the question and the booing unfair, without necessarily understanding why they may have felt that way. But on some level, both Brown and Whitman must have understood that without negativity, they had nothing to say to voters. They are the approved contestants of the California Bipolarchy, and under bipolarchy conditions candidates always feel a strong temptation to go negative. It's easier, almost instinctively so, to tell voters that your opponent is bad than to prove that you are good. When there are only two "real" choices, you're tempted to portray your opponent as the worst case scenario and an inevitable disaster to your constituents. Bipolarchy depends on there always being a "worst" candidate, one whose election can be portrayed as intolerable, so that voters feel compelled to choose either the next-strongest or the already-stronger candidate as a matter of moral (if not mortal) necessity. Bipolarchy depends on reactionary voting, on people voting against someone even while voting for someone else. Brown depends on Californians voting against Whitman, while she thinks vice versa. It makes one wonder why we don't tell voters to choose the candidate they fear the most and give elections to whoever earns the least negative votes. We don't do that, of course, because we expect citizens to vote affirmatively for the individuals they deem best qualified for office. But under bipolarchy condition the affirmative vote usually is negative in spirit. If more voters would take a wider range of candidates and parties seriously the temptation to go negative would abate, since one party's attack ads would not be guaranteed to benefit that party alone. Voters everywhere need to overcome fear -- not only the manufactured fear of the alleged worst candidate but the naive fear of entrusting power to those who don't have it already. If the voters of California despise negative campaigning so much, they should prove it by repudiating both major parties whenever the opportunity presents itself. Not until they have real rivals to deal with will Republicans and Democrats eliminate the negativity and accentuate their positives -- whatever those may be.

27 October 2010

God of Liberty

"[I]t does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty Gods, or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."

--Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia.

"Let my neighbor persuade himself that there is no God, and he will soon pick my pocket, and break not only my leg but my neck."

-- William Lind, Serious Considerations on the Election of a President (1800)

One of the ironic details Thomas S. Kidd puts toward the front of his new book, God of Liberty: A Religious History of the American Revolution is the fact that, at the end of the 18th century the religious denomination perhaps most in favor of the "separation of church and state" as understood by Jefferson were the Baptists, the group perhaps most identified with the modern "religious right" and as such presumed to oppose the separation principle. Likewise, many Baptist voters supported Jefferson despite negative campaigning that portrayed him as a militant atheist, because he was understood to support the separation principle. It helps to understand what Jefferson and his Baptist supporters understood by the "wall of separation," and God of Liberty is an admirable exercise in clarification.

Kidd contests extremist interpretations of America's founding that would portray the Founders as mostly rational Deists, on one hand, or as born-again Christians on the modern fundamentalist model, on the other. Some were one, some the other, and some were Anglicans and some were Quakers. There was no American consensus on Christian doctrine during the Founding era, though there was general agreement that belief in a creator and a day of judgment was useful if not essential to maintaining public order. Even those like Jefferson, Franklin and Washington, who verged on Deism, readily made public statements endorsing religious faith as the foundation of virtue. Beyond the two most general premises -- God and Hell, if you will, -- Christians differed on points of doctrine. That forced the question: if the state should encourage religious observance, what sort should it endorse? That question formed the context for the First Amendment and Jefferson's understanding of it as a separation of church and state.

Taxophobia in America has roots further back in time than the usual revolutionary narrative reveals. Before colonists complained against taxation without representation, many protested against one form of tax that could almost literally be interpreted as robbing Peter to pay Paul. That was the tax levied by colonies with official religious establishments for the support of sectarian clergy. Your tax dollars went to support Congregationalists in Massachusetts and Anglicans in Virginia, whether you were a Congregationalist, and Anglican, or not. As the "Great Awakening" accelerated the growth of dissenting sects like the Baptists and Methodists, dissenters increasingly resented having to subsidize denominations they didn't agree with, whose faith they sometimes questioned. The "birthers" of the 1740s were those dissenters who openly questioned whether established, subsidized pastors were really born again -- call them "rebirthers" if you like. For their trouble, dissenters often suffered persecution in colonies with official churches, at the hands both of governments and mobs.

In their long struggle against religious establishments (Massachusetts subsidized the Congregational church until 1833) the dissenters found forceful allies in the rationalists and Deists among the Founders who saw no reason for colonies or states to favor one denomination, or even one religion, over others. Under their combined influence, an American public Christianity emerged that was a kind of minimalist monotheism, acknowledging the existence of a creator (or a less anthropomorphic "Providence") and the certainty of afterlife rewards and punishments, but indifferent to finer points of controversy beyond those. Even this, however, was not a state religion, as the Framers resisted demands to embed religious qualifications for political office in the Constitution. As some critics realized with horror, the Constitution itself placed no barrier blocking Catholics, Jews, "Mahometans" or even atheists from participating in public life. Nor, Kidd adds frequently, did it block any of these people from acting publicly on the basis of their faith. None of the Founders, Kidd argues, contemplated the total "privatization" of religious morality now identified by some as a condition of the separation of church and state. None of them would have seen "legislating morality" as a breach of the Jeffersonian wall of separation. They believed it the state's essential business to encourage public morality -- which extended in their minds to the people fulfilling their obligations to the state by paying their taxes promptly.

As a "Religious History of the American Revolution," God of Liberty demonstrates how Christian concepts shaped perceptions of the conflict between the colonies and Britain. Even then, I'm afraid, people were crazy about the End Times. During the Seven Years' (French and Indian) War, colonial preachers denounced Catholic France, or the Pope France presumably served, as the Beast of Revelation. That made the British Empire a godly force for righteousness and religious liberty. But when Britain subjected the colonies to new taxes and regulations after the war, and took steps to accommodate the Catholic populations of conquered Quebec, the mother country itself assumed the Beast's role, while America became a providential nation in its own right. Even a scheme to have the Archibishop of Cantebury appoint a bishop to supervise American Anglicans drove Anglicans themselves nuts; they'd grown accustomed to local control over clergy and didn't want to give it up to an implant from Britain. Anti-Catholicism subsided once the former French enemy took the Patriots' side in the Revolutionary War, only to resurge in different circumstances in the 19th century.

On a more intellectual level, Kidd emphasizes the Christian origins of the egalitarian ideal that drove many Founders. Jefferson himself described equality as a fact of Creation in the Declaration of Independence, and Kidd shows that Jefferson gradually revised that crucial document to make God's role more "theologically explicit." This was consciously done to make the Declaration accessible to the general public, consistent with what Jefferson called "the harmonizing sentiments of the day." He could have toned the rhetoric down by following the model of his own state's Declaration of Rights, which stated simply that men were "by nature equally free and independent," but Jefferson's goal was to persuade the broadest possible American audience. This may be disappointing to some modern readers, but Kidd's account does make it clear that the Declaration's invocation of a Creator is primarily a rhetorical device rather than an affirmation of Christian faith.

Kidd saves his own editorializing for an epilogue which warns against both the abuse of Christian doctrine and rhetoric by politicians (e.g. George W. Bush) and a secularist impulse to purge religion entirely from public life. He advises today's skeptics to adopt Jefferson's pragmatism, and to recognize that "there are times when the challenges facing us require transcendent justification and moral courage beyond mere pragmatism or political preference." The Civil Rights movement under Martin Luther King's leadership was such a time, Kidd notes. He concludes that "from the Revolution to today, many Americans cannot make sense of equality and justice as rootless human preferences." At the same time, "Believers should not seek to use government to coerce anyone into religious practice." In Kidd's opinion, "it is still difficult to imagine a better source than religion for channeling American freedom toward benevolent ends." In his defense, it wasn't his job, as a historian of the 18th century, to do that imagining. But a determined secularist can still note that this final statement is something that Kidd does not prove with the thoroughness of the rest of the book. Whether the situation is really unchanged from the 18th century, or is essentially unchanging, must be learned elsewhere.

On Elites, Elitism and living in a 'bubble'

Whether Democrats lose control of Congress next week or not, tens of millions of Americans will vote for Democratic candidates, not just for the House and Senate but for statewide and local offices. Are all of these voters elitists? You'd think so from the rhetoric of some Tea Partiers, their radio idols and their Republican candidates. The word "elite" either no longer has a meaning, or the meaning has been mutated into something like "busybody," the elitist, on that dubious understanding, being anyone, regardless of class or education, who dares claim, on the basis of alleged knowledge, to tell other Americans how to live.

It's understandable if many observers dismiss this thin-skinned anti-elitism of Tea Partiers as a collective delusion, but Charles Murray (of Bell Curve fame) suggested over the weekend that there is some substance to TP suspicions. There is a "New Elite," Murray writes, if not necessarily a "New Elitism" of the kind that irks the teatotalers.

Murray points to college admission statistics, SAT scores and New York Times wedding notices that appear to prove the Bell Curve prediction of increasing "cognitive stratification" in American society. After a generation or so of leveling and relative equalization of opportunity following the opening of colleges to previously excluded groups, class divisions began to widen again with the emergence of a more meritocratic "New Elite."

The more efficiently a society identifies the most able young people of both sexes, sends them to the best colleges, unleashes them into an economy that is tailor-made for people with their abilities and lets proximity take its course, the sooner a New Elite -- the "cognitive elite" that Herrnstein and I described -- becomes a class unto itself. It is by no means a closed club, as Barack Obama's example proves. But the credentials for admission are increasingly held by the children of those who are already members. An elite that passes only money to the next generation is evanescent ("Shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations," as the adage has it). An elite that also passes on ability is more tenacious, and the chasm between it and the rest of society widens.


While Murray notes a "left" ideological bias among the New Elite as a whole, he's quick to point out that many right-wing decision and opinion makers also belong to the New Elite. "[T]he politics of the New Elite are not the main point," he clarifies, "When it comes to the schools where they were educated, the degrees they hold, the Zip codes where they reside and the television shows they watch, I doubt if there is much to differentiate the staff of the conservative Weekly Standard from that of the liberal New Republic, or the scholars at the American Enterprise Institute from those of the Brookings Institution, or Republican senators from Democratic ones."

Membership in the New Elite, then, doesn't automatically instill the "elitist" attitude perceived and abhorred by Tea Partiers. If anything, Murray suggests, the New Elite is guilty of a more passive elitism, an elitism of alienation or ignorance of "mainstream America." The New Elite, he claims, is increasingly segregated residentially from the rest of America due to its tendency to mate within its own ranks. It's increasingly segregated professionally, holding few "jobs in businesses that provide bread-and-butter goods and services to individual Americans." As a result, the New Elite lives in a kind of bubble, isolated from contact with non-elite America.

With geographical clustering goes cultural clustering. Get into a conversation about television with members of the New Elite, and they can probably talk about a few trendy shows -- "Mad Men" now, "The Sopranos" a few years ago. But they haven't any idea who
replaced Bob Barker on "The Price Is Right." They know who Oprah is, but they've never watched one of her shows from beginning to end. Talk to them about sports, and you may get an animated discussion of yoga, pilates, skiing or mountain biking, but they are unlikely to know who Jimmie Johnson is (the really famous Jimmie Johnson, not the former Dallas Cowboys coach), and the acronym MMA means nothing to them. They can talk about books endlessly, but they've never read a
"Left Behind" novel (65 million copies sold) or a Harlequin romance (part of a genre with a core readership of 29 million Americans)....There are so many quintessentially American things that few members of the New Elite have experienced. They probably haven't ever attended a meeting of a Kiwanis Club or Rotary Club, or lived for at least a year in a small town (college doesn't count) or in an urban neighborhood in which most of their neighbors did not have college degrees (gentrifying neighborhoods don't count). They are unlikely to have spent at least a year with a family income less than twice the poverty line (graduate school doesn't count) or to have a close friend who is an evangelical Christian. They are unlikely to have even visited a factory floor, let alone worked on one.


These distinctions may be trivial in detail, but Murray believes that they add up to a cultural gulf that leads those self-consciously outside the elite, the Tea Partiers in particular, to feel that the New Elites "don't get America." Murray himself is more generous, but still critical. "They are not defective in their patriotism or lacking a generous spirit toward their fellow citizens. They are merely isolated and ignorant. The members of the New Elite may love America, but, increasingly, they are not of it."

Being part of an elite and living in a bubble are two different things, however, and living in a bubble is not a privilege of class. Murray is guilty of a crude majoritarian presumption that whatever is popular is thus "quintessentially" American. For every proof Murray offers of the elites' bubbled isolation, an equivalent proof can be offered to show how a similar bubble isolates NASCAR-loving, gameshow-watching, Harlequin-reading, Rotary Club America from a "high" culture that has just as much claim to be "quintessential." Would Murray agree that there are at least some "quintessentially" American experiences from which Tea Partiers are isolated, of which they are ignorant, willfully or not? Would he concede that some phenomena that TPs deem quintessential aren't necessarily so for all Americans? In a demographically pluralist polity, no raw numerical majority can dictate that its experiences and interests are quintessential, just as no group has the right to call another a "special interest." Our political leaders need to understand the economic interests and public-safety needs of all classes of Americans, but cultural empathy is a lower priority. Someone's indifference to Oprah's schedule of guests should not disqualify them from public trust. Nor should a willingness to tell Americans how to live, as long as the final decision is put to a vote. Democracy, after all, is nothing but all of us telling each other how to live -- and somehow living together anyway.

26 October 2010

Is independent centrism impossible?

Newsweek gives historian Kevin Baker space this week to scoff at Thomas Friedman's call for a new party of the "radical center" to challenge the increasingly polarized two-party system. Baker dismisses similar advocacy from David Brooks as well, arguing that insurgency in American political history always comes from the fringes, never from the middle -- or what Baker sneeringly calls the "Terribly Sensible Party." Baker makes the common claim that third parties have been useful only insofar as they force major parties to address the concerns of newly articulate and organized outsiders. Outsiders, by Baker's implicit definition, can't be centrists. They make demands that are always seen as extreme by the establishment, whether the outsiders stake their positions on the "left" or the "right."

Moderation or centrism implies a principled willingness to compromise that Baker deems alien to American political experience. Compromise, he claims, comes only when one side is exhausted or intimidated into backing down from its extreme demands. " Change in America is all about large, often primal forces smashing into each other, until somebody gives ground or a ramshackle compromise is finally hammered out," he writes, "That's democratic politics in all its awful splendor, and it's especially true when times are bad and radical solutions are seen as necessary."

Baker sees less willingness to compromise than ever on the contemporary political landscape. He takes the ideological bipolarization of the majority of the electorate for granted. "Where are the voters for the would-be sensible third party?" he asks, "Liberals think we can have big public projects and pay generous wages and benefits to public employees, too. Conservatives aren't clamoring to slash these same wages and benefits so they can make judicious new public investments. Instead, they want to shrink government, privatize it as much as possible, and turn the savings into tax cuts. The differences on any number of other issues are just as deep and unbridgeable."

Today's mood is especially uncompromising, Baker claims, because the nation is torn between two simultaneous insurgencies. "Over the last two election cycles, both the right-wing, libertarian Tea Party and a rather inchoate, more or less liberal movement centered around Barack Obama have sprung up. They are likely to battle it out for some time to come. The argument they are having may often be ugly, but there is no common ground between them, sensible or otherwise." Despite all his wishy-washy qualifiers, Baker wants us to think of Obama's constituency as an insurgency, and by his own implicit definition extremist. Whether Obama-ism (for want of any other label) or Tea Partyism really represent any kind of uprising of the excluded, or anything new under the political sun, is highly debatable.

Thomas Friedman holds out hope for a now mostly silent but subterraneously simmering radical center. By his definition, it would not surprise Friedman if Baker can't see the radical center on the field right now. Friedman's salvation might seem too technocratic for some people's taste, and the columnist has been accused for some time now of a longing for authoritarian rule. But the concept of the radical center remains promising despite its oxymoronic sound. How can a center be radical? How about when it's the "center" only in the imagination of the "left" and "right," each of whom see the center only as a realm of compromise and weak will? Draw two halves of a circle to enclose a space on the page. The enclosed space is of the same substance as the space outside the circle. The center is the same as the outside. Left and right tell us that our options are constrained by the barriers they draw to contain us. Under such conditions, it may well be radical, if not extreme, to observe that the circle does not contain everything, and is arbitrarily drawn. For all I know, Baker may think of himself as a moderate trapped in the center of the eternal circle of ideological bipolarchy. From what I can tell, he thinks that right and left are intractable facts and permanent organizing principles of the political cosmos. How much more radical can you get than to say that he is wrong?

25 October 2010

They're out to destroy ME?

To be specific, the scare quote on the front of the envelope read, "They're Out to Destroy You." The envelope came from The Nation, and inside was a pitch for The Nation Associates. The revered progressive weekly can't support itself on the income from subscriptions, newsstand sales and advertising alone, the pitch explains so on top of my $79.95 subscription The Nation wants a further subsidy from me in the form of an Associates membership of $35 or more.

But no, it's not The Nation that's out to destroy me or my bank account. Actually, their sole authority for anyone's destructive intentions toward me is an unidentified "political analyst" who actually said, "They are out to destroy progressives."

"That's you -- and that's us," the pitch writer helpfully adds. But this was an Edmond O'Brien moment when, in the manner of the crazy old coot from The Wild Bunch, I have to ask, "Who the hell is they?" The answer was prompt.

Who? The conservative elite that increasingly controls this nation's wealth -- and the credulous media they can buy to advance their ultimate end game: the abolition of Social Security, minimum-wage laws, gun control, a woman's right to choose, all personal and corporate income taxes, corporate regulation.


Find someone who advocates all of the above and you do have a bad guy, but I'm not sure if any politician has been so bold, even in this season. But it isn't the politicians driving the agenda; according to the Nation Associates, it's the Koch Brothers, fast becoming the counterparts in progressive demonology to George Soros for the right-wingers. The Koch's most terrifying donation, or at least the scariest one the pitch writer cares to cite, was to the diabolical Cato Institute. I'm sure all of you tremble at the thought of a richly-funded libertarian think tank, but fear not: your donation to the Nation Associates will help rebalance the scales, since the magazine's "influence in exposing the motives and malfeasance of corporate power and media is huge -- and as the country's oldest magazine of opinion -- peerless." The Kochs and Catos of America fear The Nation because it's "a united voice that gets heard above the din" and "still the most widely read and highly respected weekly journal of news and opinion in America." Believe it or not.

I read The Nation loyally but I think they flatter themselves here. I doubt that America's evil billionaires feel threatened by an opinion magazine that by its nature preaches to a choir and is unlikely to change anybody's mind about anything. It's more likely that they remain more concerned with stamping out what remains of "liberal bias" in television news, or with their new project of ending government's token support for National Public Radio. The Nation also exaggerates its stake in the midterm elections. "If we lose this fight," the letter reads, "and the major test that is just ahead with the November elections -- things are going to get a lot tougher." In fact, the worst case scenario for the country may be the best for The Nation. When conservatives rule, progressive media flourish in opposition. The George W. Bush years were a bonanza for dissident media. Print media still faces the challenge of perceived obsolescence in the internet age, but it's a stretch to tie that to a conspiracy of reactionary oligarchs.

Almost all opinion journals make this kind of pitch these days. They're the equivalent of pledge drives for public radio, and I sympathize with the straitened circumstances that force them to beg for something above and beyond a subscription renewal. I'm just not in any position to help them, beyond renewing, and some of these journals (like The American Conservative) may be beyond help, not because of any conspiracy against them, but because of changing times and changing channels of intellectual communication. When print magazines cry, "they're out to destroy us," the correct response may be less Edmond O'Brien and more Clint Eastwood -- something along the lines of, "you've all got it coming" and "deserve's got nothing to do with it."

Are the People never wrong?

In a column picked up by the Albany paper, San Antonio columnist Jonathan Gurwitz scores some cheap populist points against Democrats. Taking the anti-elitist argument nearly as far as it will go, Gurwitz equates the Obama administration to the East German communist regime of 1953, the object of a famous satire from Bertolt Brecht, himself a German communist, who suggested speciously in the face of strikes that the government might be better off appointing a new population in place of the present uncooperative citizenry. To Gurwitz, any attempt to attribute opposition to Democratic policies to error or unreason is equivalent to the Communist attitude satirized by Brecht. It's easy to take quotes out of context (specifically the context of Republican fearmongering) to make Democrats look smug, arrogant and, yes, elitist. For Gurwitz, such quotes prove the Democrats to be tone-deaf egoists asking for their comeuppance. Daring to tell voters that they might be wrong is the same as wanting to "elect the citizenry," East German style.

It was a predictable enough conservative commentary and probably not worth commentary from me, except that I found myself thinking what Gurwitz might think about the situation in France. There, a conservative government (by French standards) is ramming through an increase in the state pension age as the entering wedge of an austerity program. The government is meeting mass resistance in the form of demonstrations and some rioting. Gurwitz may have his own opinion on the propriety of street demonstrations, but would he consider it President Sarkozy's business to tell the angry masses in the streets of Paris and other cities that they're wrong, that their opposition to an arguably necessary reform is irrational and possibly self-defeating in the long run? If Gurwitz himself is conservative, he probably has had some sharp words in his head for the demonstrators, if he's given them any thought. Would that mean that he thinks that Gurwitz should dismiss the current French population and elect another? What about when the next Republican government in this country actually tries to push through an austerity program of massive cuts to social welfare programs? What if Americans, through some prodigy, take to the streets to resist. Would Gurwitz be willing, on behalf of a Republican regime, to tell the people that their opposition is based on error, unreason or poor moral character? American conservatives often console themselves with the thought that a "silent majority" always agrees with their views, but when confronted by the most vocal minority, would Gurwitz expect Republicans not to make the same arguments that Democrats have made in the face of the most vocal opposition to their policies?

In order to play the populist for a day, Gurwitz is trying to throw out the baby or leadership with the bathwater of alleged elitism. Some Republicans (Cal Thomas is a noteworthy example) acknowledge that their plan to wean Americans off dependence on government will require some form of moral or intellectual leadership when it comes to educating the public about the supposed necessity and desirability of the changes they propose. Thomas has no illusion that austerity will be an easy sell, and his ideal of moral leadership includes a readiness to tell the people when they've gone astray. A litany of Republican apologetics could end up looking as selectively damning to the knee-jerk anti-elitist as Gurwitz's anthology of Democratic condescension. Would Gurwitz respond to it similarly, or would that be when he'd choose the Brechtian option, "to dissolve the people and elect another?"

If the President doesn't toe the party line, why should you?

The Democratic candidate for governor of Rhode Island is pissed at the President of the United States. Readers may recall that Barack Obama is a Democrat himself, but he has decided not to endorse the Democrat, nor any other candidate, in the Rhode Island race, a four-way campaign. The aggrieved Democrat believes that the President has denied him the endorsement he considers his partisan due in order to pay a political debt to Lincoln Chafee, a renegade Republican who endorsed Obama for President in 2008 and is running as an independent for governor this year. It's a small debt if it didn't oblige Obama to actually endorse Chafee, but all involved probably realize that it would be a step too far in the current political environment for a partisan President to declare in favor of an independent over a fellow Democrat. Nevertheless, Obama's refusal to endorse the Democrat may be seen as a passive endorsement of Chafee, if not a statement of principled indifference to the outcome in Rhode Island. However, die-hard partisans might well ask whether the symbolic leader of the Democrats himself suffers from the dreaded "enthusiasm gap" plaguing the party's traditional constituencies this year. Throughout the country this week, Democratic spokespersons are asking voters to hold their noses, literally or not, and vote the ruling party, if only to prevent the fate worse than death, Republican rule in Congress. Die-hard Democrats might well expect the President to set an example of closed-nose voting for the straight ticket. Instead, he has taught a lesson whether he meant to or not. Without putting it in so many words, he has told Rhode Islanders that the future of their state, at least, doesn't depend upon the election of a Democratic governor. It makes you wonder why that shouldn't be true elsewhere.

22 October 2010

An exclusive Senatorial debate and a rhetorical question

Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat appointed by the governor of New York to fill the vacancy created by Hilary Clinton's elevation to the State Department, and one of her challengers for the remaining two years of Clinton's term, Republican Joseph DioGuardi, held a one-hour debate in Troy last night. It was a dull affair with mostly predictable answers to predictable questions. A low point seemed to come during a "lightning round," when the candidates were obliged to give yes or no answers to a rapid succession of questions. Some questions were suited to the rule, and some were intended for laughs, e.g., "Is the rent too damn high?" In the midst of the flurry, my ears perked up when the moderator asked, "Should Andrew Cuomo and Carl Paladino hold a one-on-one debate?" DioGuardi said yes. Gillibrand said no. Then DioGuardi ad-libbed, "We are."

It was a succinct exchange of honest exclusionary impulse and hypocrisy. Whether Gillibrand meant to say that any future gubernatorial debate should also include the five independent candidates, or that Cuomo was under no obligation to debate Paladino alone, her opposition to the idea was put in contrast to her own participation in an exclusive debate. DioGuardi's affirmative answer, meanwhile, was a blunt endorsement of the exclusionary principle.

Last night's debate organizers had, in fact, excluded four independent candidates for Gillibrand's seat. Vivia Morgan is the candidate of the Anti-Prohibition party; she supports the legalization of casinos and marijuana as well as tax cuts for working people and businesses alike. Cecile Lawrence, the Green candidate, wants to end American subsidies for polluting corporations, an 85% reduction in American military presence abroad, single-payer national health insurance, and free undergraduate college education for all Americans who graduate high school. John Clifton, the Libertarian candidate, also wants to bring the troops home, but would also end the "war on drugs," along with the IRS and the Federal Reserve. Finally, the Rent is 2 Damn High party has Joseph Huff on the ballot, but the candidate's website was recently shut down, and this interview from September expresses his ambivalence about associating with James McMillan. To my knowledge, Charles Barron's Freedom Party is not running a candidate against Gillibrand, who is herself endorsed by the Independence and Working Families parties. DioGuardi appears on the Conservative and Taxpayers lines.

Can anyone who watched last night's debate argue that more "ideas" were expressed or exchanged between the two Bipolarchy candidates than were expressed at Monday's inclusive gubernatorial debate? At best, biased observers can claim that they heard more of the ideas they consider legitimate or viable, but what they've really wanted all along in every race is a clear, simple presentation of the candidates already determined to have a "real chance" of winning, hardly considering that it should be up to them, as viewers of an inclusive debate, to decide afterwards which candidates have real chances. Too many Americans are still concerned more about being on the winning team or betting on the winning horse than with making the best choice or simply expressing their own reasoned preferences. They're afraid of feeling like fools for picking someone without a "real" chance of winning, even within the privacy of the secret ballot. Why they don't feel more foolish constantly shuttling back and forth, if they're "independent," between the two big parties, is to date an unsolved mystery.

21 October 2010

No 'Exchange of Ideas' in Inclusive Debates?

James V. Franco took his parting shot at the seven-candidate New York gubernatorial debate in today's Troy Record. Before the event took place, he complained that the inclusion of five independent candidates would divert the debate from what he deemed its proper purpose, which was to put front-runner Andrew Cuomo on the spot throughout. He reports today that the event itself left him "just shaking my head."

A candidate from The Rent is 2 Damn High Party. A former madame. A candidate who during his introduction said a black person or an Asian should be asking the questions. There were seven in all and each was given the same amount of time to answer and rebut the same questions.It was a circus, not an exchange of, or challenge to, ideas.


Franco's comments beg the question of how he defines "ideas." My hunch is that he simply didn't hear enough of the "ideas" he already believed in, nor the "ideas" he dislikes challenged often enough. He makes clear yet again today that the only proper subject for a gubernatorial debate in his mind is "Is Andrew Cuomo qualified to be governor, pro or con?" Nothing that is not a direct challenge to Cuomo and his "ideas" is worth Franco's time. That's why, even though he's given up hope for Carl Paladino's Republican candidacy, he still feels that Cuomo should debate Paladino mano-i-mano. Monday's debate was worthless, in his view, because "Having seven people [ad hominem comments redacted] dilutes Cuomo’s exposure." He thinks that Cuomo insisted on having all the independents on stage Monday for exactly that reason, when it was Paladino, from what I've read, who insisted on the most inclusive debate.

Since his last, pre-debate column, Franco has looked up the debate mandate of the Commission on Presidential Elections. He's found that the CPE is supposed to “ensure that debates, as a permanent part of every general election, provide the best possible information to viewers and listeners." The "best possible information" clause would be his justification for excluding Kristin Davis, for instance. "Somehow, I get the feeling a former madame making homophobe jokes wouldn’t get an invite," he writes. Davis isn't running for President, of course, but Franco has written previously that the CPE's more exclusionary debate guidelines should have been applied to the gubernatorial candidates in New York. Never mind that she played by the rules and has an equal ballot line to the Democratic and Republican candidates; Citizen Franco has judged her a second-class candidate.

My own proposal for revamping the debate format, which I posted yesterday, would give voters an opportunity to pass just such a judgment, but not before Davis or any other allegedly frivolous candidate has at least one chance to make her case to the state as a legal equal to all the other candidates. People like Franco are annoyed at Davis or James McMillan getting even that one opportunity, as their criticisms of the Hofstra debate attest. They have an objective cause for complaint in the debate organizers' failure to take more time for seven candidates than they usually reserve for only two. But I doubt whether Franco would have been more satisfied with the exchange of ideas in a longer format. While he makes a favorable mention of Lincoln and Douglas today, he thinks that their 1858 three-hour debate format "may be a bit much" by today's standards. Worse, no extension of time is likely to make him more tolerant of alternate voices. He still finds Paladino "refreshing" because he "talked like he was hanging out at a diner or a pub not like he was on stage reading a script," but I wonder whether he'd be as tolerant of Paladino's refreshing manner if the Buffalo businessman were only the Taxpayers party candidate distracting from Rick Lazio's challenge to Cuomo. Without the GOP brand label, unconventional oratory only irritates Franco. He claims to want an alternative to business-as-usual in Albany, but his attitude toward indisputable alternatives standing in front of him makes me wonder how badly he actually wants change.

Admit Islamophobia and You're Fired

The conservatives are going to be right about this one, I think: in an excess of political correctness, National Public Radio has fired longtime correspondent Juan Williams for admitting to a degree of Islamophobia during an appearance on The O'Reilly Factor. Williams is a regular sort of house progressive for Fox News, and was debating O'Reilly about the Islamophobic comments the host himself had made as a guest on The View last week when he admitted that he felt uncomfortable riding in airplanes with Muslims. He then went on to transcend his emotions and criticize O'Reilly for generalizing about Muslims in more overtly offensive fashion -- the right-wing talker had said that he opposed the "Ground Zero mosque" project because "Muslims" had destroyed the World Trade Center, but apologized later on The View.

Based on the excerpts from the O'Reilly-Williams exchange published by MSNBC, Williams was clearly talking about his own feelings and not actually generalizing about Muslims in an accusatory fashion. But the Council on American-Islamic Relations missed the distinction and accused Williams of saying that all Muslims on airplanes were security risks. Meanwhile, MSNBC makes it sound like NPR was looking for an excuse for dumping Williams, having disliked the implication that he somehow represented the radio network on Fox News.

Predictably, some reactionaries, already resenting the network's "liberal bias," are using the Williams affair as an excuse to pressure Congress to withdraw funding from NPR. That's excessive, but this is clearly a case in which political correctness deserves criticism. Williams himself appears to have made the correct distinction between gut feelings and public policies that should not be determined by gut feelings, while CAIR appears to have taken the unrealistic position that no one should even admit to gut feelings in public. While the state should still presume individual Muslims innocent until they give material cause for suspicion, nothing short of thought-control can force all individuals to make the same presumption, and nothing short of censorship can compel them to keep their suspicions quiet.

If I may be allowed to generalize, too many Muslims are thin-skinned. I won't attempt to speculate on the reasons, though I will acknowledge some understandable anxiety about the possibility of hate crime, but Muslims often seem to be more intolerant of perceived insults than any other group of people on earth. Few people other than Muslims seem so ready to answer perceived insults -- even unintended ones -- with violence. In this country, some people would resent Muslims for their thin-skinnedness (i.e. "political correctness")alone, before you add history and current events to the equation. In the U.S., we may still dream of brotherhood as children, but most of us are reconciled to the fact that many of our fellow citizens will never like us, for political reasons if not for anything else. We are able to live together regardless of mutual dislike by refusing to resent the fact. Muslim Americans are understandably resentful of the suspicion aimed at a once-model minority only recently, but suspicion and dislike are not crimes. Muslims themselves should avoid generalizations: not everyone who looks crossly or worriedly at you is going to beat you up or burn your mosque. Not everyone who admits to nervousness in the presence of observant Muslims is their enemy. I have no way to know whether CAIR's complaints influenced NPR's decision to fire Williams. But if I were part of CAIR, I wouldn't care to claim credit for it. Today's news won't make any American respect Muslims any more than they did before; I hope it won't make them respect them any less.

To judge Williams for yourselves, take a look at the complete transcript on this site of his dialogue with O'Reilly.